Six years in the making and only their third full-length album, Seattle’s Fleet Foxes have continued to nurture their own course in music without bucking to popular trends or the pressures of commercial necessity. Their new album, Crack-Up (Nonesuch) is a grand affair with sweeping musical dynamics and tales about Greek nymphs, personal doubt and the fragility of life. It was recorded in six different studios in six different cities in the United States and clocks in at 55 minutes in length. I mention these facts because Crack-Up is best heard in one sitting. Symphonic-like in structure most of the tracks segue from one to the other joining the individual parts of the whole work. Like many of the Prog-rock albums of the seventies, the music, tales and their structure suggest a concept album, but Fleet Foxes is best known as contemporary folk band in most circles, so Crack-Up is a roots hybrid; grand in scope but without the spectacle and technical self-indulgence of Progressive Rock.
Fleet Foxes principal songwriter is Robin Pecknold who started writing songs as teenager. Growing up in Seattle, Pecknold didn’t find much stimulation in the Grunge music scene popularized by Nirvana, because he was inspired by the work of Bob Dylan and dedicated himself to writing songs in a folk/roots tradition. At the age of 20 Pecknold formed the band Fleet Foxes in 2006 with Skyler Skjelset who he befriended in high school. The pair shared a fondness for the music of Dylan and Neil Young two artists equally at home in rock, folk and country music formats. That blending of acoustic and electric sounds came to distinguish Fleet Foxes. Like their first two albums, Crack-Up is very much a mix of the quiet, acoustic sounds of folk with the louder, more energized sounds of Rock ‘N Roll. But unlike the Prog-rock bands of 40 years ago, such as Yes and Genesis, the musicianship is not as sophisticated or technically astute. Fleet Foxes play their instruments well, but you won’t hear any extended keyboard or guitar solos typical of the Prog-Rock era.
Crack-Up takes its name and inspiration from a series of essays by F. Scott Fitzgerald that were published in Esquire Magazine. Written in three separate issues the piece is one of the most insightful examinations of an artist’s creative breakdown and how he coped with it. Fitzgerald goes to great lengths using long-winded sentences to explain how he “cracked up” after all the fame and success he achieved as a writer in his youth. It’s a cumbersome read but interesting to anyone in a creative slump. I certainly learned a lot about Fitzgerald as a thinker, someone who understood how humans struggle with choice particularly when they have too many. His essay in Esquire was published in 1936 near the end of his career and after reading it, I couldn’t help but think of it as a literary hangover dissertation. Fitzgerald was a heavy drinker and the essay reads like a long, drawn out morning after “hair-of-the-dog”. That said, Robin Pecknold was inspired by a few of the many philosophical nuggets of Fitzgerald’s piece, namely, the notion of a cracked dish and whether it, “is worth preserving”. Fitzgerald writes, “The cracked plate has to be retained in the pantry, has to be kept in service as a household necessity. It can never again be warmed on the stove nor shuffled with the other plates in the dishpan; it will not be brought out for company, but it will do to hold crackers late at night or to go into the icebox under leftovers…” It’s an interesting metaphor for a struggling, self-conscious writer looking to recoup his muse, but offers only a gateway into Fleet Foxes latest recording. There’s a little more going on in Robin Pecknold’s 11 songs here.
The cover image on Crack-Up offers an important clue to the record’s focus. It’s a photograph by Hiroshi Hamaya capturing the rough and rocky shoreline at Tojinbo, Japan, famous, unfortunately, as one of the places where people go to commit suicide. It’s 70-foot cliffs rise from a rough sea formed by volcanoes millions of years ago. The clashes of the salt water against the rocks have greatly eroded them over time. In musical terms this is how Crack-Up plays out. It ebbs and flows like an ocean crashing against the rocky shore right from the first track. Long periods of calm interrupt the pace of the continuous flow of the musical soundscape on the record. Pecknold’s subjects ebb and flow as well as he taps into mythology “Naiads, Cassadies” with references to ancient Romans, “Cassius”.
Yet despite these often-recurring characters there is variety within the album’s wider scope. For instance we get a political song, “If You Need To, Keep Time On Me” specifically referencing January 20, 2017, on the Inauguration of Donald Trump. “Fool’s Errand” is a song of hope among the turmoil and I like the humour of “I Should See Memphis” that sets us up for the last track. But there’s too much sameness to the songs in their tone and arrangements. Many of the tracks crescendo from quiet whispers, but the overall feel of the record is undeveloped because it leaves no room for improvisation. At no point did I hear anything spontaneous on the record and while I admire the band for taking the time to write and perform music like this in our short-attention-span-2017, the earthiness of their music, which is often revealed in their concerts, isn’t evident on this recording.
Only one song refers to specifically Fitzgerald’s essay and although it’s the last one, I’m not really sure what journey I’ve been a part of nor am I sure what to conclude. Is this record symbolic of Pecknold’s own artistic crisis? Is the band trying to reach a new musical plateau? Perhaps the answer lies at the very end of the album. As the 4-piece brass group known as The Westerlies play a series of solemn chords, Pecknold quietly states “all things change…dividing tides rising over me.” This column first appeared on CriticsAtLarge on July 12, 2017.